Craftsmanship That Celebrates Life’s Milestones
Blue Water Jewelers is growing again — and this Fall 2026, we’re opening a brand‑new location on Highway 312 on Anastasia Island, just east of the 312 Bridge near Black Molly Grill and Barwick Bank. Positioned along one of the island’s busiest corridors, this new home offers quick access from St. Augustine, St. Augustine Beach, Anastasia Island, Davis Shores, St. Augustine Shores, Butler Beach, Crescent Beach, and communities stretching toward World Golf Village and US‑1 South. Whether you’re coming from the mainland, the beaches, or historic downtown, our showroom will be only minutes away.
Our new location sits at a key crossroads connecting the mainland to Anastasia Island, keeping us close to the St. Augustine Lighthouse, A1A Beach Boulevard, and the area’s beautiful coastline — a perfect reflection of the community we’re proud to serve.
Rooted in St. Augustine since 2006, Blue Water Jewelers began as a small shop on Old Dixie Highway, where Robert Nettles set out to create a jewelry experience built on artistry, trust, and genuine care. When Nicole Nettles joined him, that vision grew into something even more meaningful. In 2010, we moved into the historic Bank of Anastasia Building, which became more than a storefront — it became a gathering place, a creative hub, and a familiar stop for generations of local families. From hosting the Love Your Mother Earth Fashion Show to welcoming visitors into our working jewelry bench and workshop, our story has always been intertwined with the community around us.
